Skip to content
About us & Why FlameCrafters? Delivery Easy Returns Contact Us Privacy Terms Of Service
Log Burner vs Electric Fire: Which One Will Light Up Your Home?
January 4, 2025

Log Burner vs Electric Fire: Which One Will Light Up Your Home?

Log Burner vs. Electric Fire: A Comparison

Choosing between a log burner and an electric fire can feel like deciding between a cosy cabin retreat and a sleek modern flat. Both bring warmth, but they do it in very different ways. Let’s walk you through everything you need to know so you can make the right choice for your home.

Heat Output and Efficiency

Log Burner Efficiency

Log burners are heat powerhouses. Picture a roaring fire, glowing embers, and the entire room toasty warm—even your toes under the table. A well-maintained log burner can reach an efficiency of 70-85%, especially when burning properly seasoned wood.

What’s seasoned wood? It’s wood that’s been dried out to burn clean and hot. While it takes a bit of effort to store and manage, the payoff is unbeatable warmth and a classic crackling atmosphere.

Electric Fire Efficiency

Electric fires, on the other hand, are the epitome of convenience. They convert close to 100% of the electricity they use into heat. No chopping logs or hauling wood inside—just a quick flick of the switch.

However, their heat is best suited for smaller spaces. They excel at providing a consistent warmth and can be adjusted at the push of a button, often with a handy remote. If you love the idea of controlling your room temperature from your sofa, an electric fire fits the bill.

Running Costs

Environmental Impact

Log burners, when paired with sustainably sourced wood, can be surprisingly eco-friendly. Wood is renewable, after all. However, they do release smoke and particulates into the air, which means they’re not always the cleanest option.

Electric fires produce no direct emissions—they don’t even need ventilation! But their carbon footprint depends on where your electricity comes from. If you’re hooked up to renewable energy, your impact is minimal. If it’s fossil fuels, though, that’s a different story.

Aesthetics and Atmosphere

There’s no denying the appeal of a real fire. The flickering flames, the smell of burning wood, and that satisfying crackle can make even the coldest night feel magical. A log burner is like bringing a piece of the countryside indoors.

Electric fires have come a long way, though. Many models boast incredibly realistic flame effects, complete with glowing embers. You can even customise the flame colour and intensity. While they may lack the sound and smell of real wood, they’re still a stylish addition to any home.

Advantages of Log Burners

Cost Savings (Long-Term)

The upfront cost of a log burner is nothing to sneeze at. However, over time, you can save money—especially if you have a local source of affordable or free firewood. Once the stove is installed, wood is generally cheaper than electricity.

Eco-Friendly Alternative

If you burn sustainably sourced wood, a log burner becomes a low-carbon option. It’s a great way to reduce your reliance on the grid, especially during peak times when demand (and prices) spike.

Unique Ambiance

There’s something primal about gathering around a real fire. The crackling logs, the dancing flames—it’s like stepping back in time while staying snug in your living room. A log burner doesn’t just warm your home; it creates an atmosphere that’s hard to replicate.

Disadvantages of Log Burners

Maintenance Requirements

Log burners require commitment. You’ll need to clean out the ashes, sweep the chimney, and regularly inspect for wear and tear. If you forget, you could end up with a chimney fire—a risk no homeowner wants.

Installation Costs

Installing a log burner isn’t a simple DIY job. You’ll need a chimney or a flue, professional installation, and you may need to adhere to building regulations. Costs can quickly add up, ranging from hundreds to thousands of pounds.

Space Considerations

A log burner takes up space—both for the stove itself and for storing firewood. If your home is compact or lacks an outdoor area for wood storage, it might not be practical.

Advantages of Electric Fires

Convenience and Ease of Use

Electric fires are simplicity itself. No wood to chop, no ashes to sweep—just plug it in and enjoy. Many come with remotes and programmable settings, making it easy to adjust the heat without leaving your cosy spot.

Safety

Since there’s no real flame, electric fires are safer for homes with children or pets. There’s no risk of sparks or smoke, and the glass panels on modern models stay cool to the touch.

Installation

Forget costly installations. Most electric fires just need a nearby plug socket. Whether you want a wall-mounted, freestanding, or built-in design, you’ll have plenty of options to fit your room.

Disadvantages of Electric Fires

Running Costs

Electricity prices can be high, so running an electric fire all day can get pricey. It’s worth considering how often you’ll use it and what your electricity tariff looks like.

Environmental Impact

The eco-friendliness of an electric fire depends entirely on your energy source. If your home uses green energy, you’re golden. If not, your carbon footprint could be higher than you’d expect.

Lack of Real Fire Ambiance

Even the best electric fire can’t fully recreate the multisensory experience of a real fire. The sound of crackling logs and the subtle scent of burning wood simply can’t be replicated. If that’s what you crave, an electric fire may feel like a compromise.

Conclusion

When it comes to choosing between a log burner and an electric fire, it all comes down to what matters most to you. Want a classic, cosy feel with a touch of nostalgia? A log burner could be your dream choice. Prefer instant heat, ease of use, and a modern aesthetic? An electric fire might suit you better.

Think about your space, lifestyle, and budget before you decide—and whichever you choose, enjoy every warm and wonderful moment it brings.

 

Other content we think you'll love

Previous article Log Burner vs Central Heating: Best Home Heating Option Explained
Next article Log Burner vs Multi-Fuel Stove: Which One is Right for Your Home?